Author Archives: hemingray

SongoftheSouth.net News Overhauled

Notice anything different? In preparation for SongoftheSouth.net’s 10th Anniversary next month, I’m giving this site some much-needed TLC. The biggest enhancement so far is this News section, one of this site’s most visited features. Gone are the old static pages; from now on, this section will be powered by WordPress, a popular and powerful blogging tool. This benefits you, the reader, in several ways:

  1. You can now leave comments on the articles posted here.
  2. Searching archived news is now simple, either by keyword or tags.
  3. Find news by Category, such as Rumors or Collectible announcements.
  4. RSS feeds are now available for easy subscription.

This also benefits me because there’s less maintenance; pages are dynamically updated via PHP. Posting news is so much easier now, this has turned out to be one of those “gee, wish I’d done this years ago!” moments. There’s more site enhancements in store for the coming months, so stay tuned!

Warner Brothers to Release “Censored Eleven” Next Year

While not directly related to Song of the South, this is a very significant breakthrough in the realm of cartoon censorship. The Censored Eleven is a collection of Looney Toons and Merrie Melodies cartoons created between 1931 and 1944 that were withheld from syndication by United Artists in 1968 because they were deemed too racially insensitive. This censorship persisted through Ted Turner’s acquisition of pre-1948 Warner Brothers cartoons in 1986. While commercially unavailable, these cartoons have been circulating around the Internet for years, including sites such as YouTube. (Sounds like some other film we know of… hmmm…)

Then, in February of this year, Warner Brothers purportedly tested the waters to release these censored cartoons by having a special screening at the first annual TCM Classic Film Festival. Most recently, at the New York ComicCon held this month, Warner Brothers confirmed that they will indeed be releasing the Censored Eleven on the Warner Archives collection sometime in 2011. Source: ToonZone

What impact could this potentially have for Song of the South? If these cartoons are indeed released, perhaps Disney will follow suit and finally make this much maligned (and much tamer) film available to the American public. Interestingly, some of the other Warner Brother cartoons released on DVD in the past include a foreword by Whoopi Goldberg, stating that while many of the cartoons contain behavior which was, and still is, not acceptable, these cartoons are a vital part of history and should not be forgotten. Sound familiar? Many supporters of Song of the South‘s release have suggested this same type of introduction. Maybe with Warner Brothers leading by example, Disney will finally listen?

More information about the Censored Eleven can be found on Wikipedia. Thanks to Zack and Wiwille for the news report!

Article Details Song of the South’s Filming History in Arizona

In an article written on June 11th, Richard Ruelas of the Arizona Republic details the ties of Song of the South to the state of Arizona. The state has two important links to this movie: First, it was at a Phoenix school playground where Glenn Leedy was discovered by a talent scout and recruited for the role of Toby; and second, the majority of Song of the South‘s outdoor scenes were actually filmed at a ranch in Phoenix.

The full article is available here. Thanks to Tom for the news report!

New 2010 WDCC Song of the South Figurine Set

For the first time since 1996, this summer’s Walt Disney Classics Collection release includes Song of the South themed figurines. Entitled “Brer Fox & Brer Rabbit: Cooking Up a Plan/Last Laugh”, the set depicts Brer Rabbit and Brer Fox from the beginning of the Laughing Place sequence of Song of the South, in which Brer Fox is about to cook up Brer Rabbit. Interestingly, Song of the South isn’t mentioned at all in the official product description:

“Walt Disney loved the animal fables penned by Joel Chandler Harris in which clever Brer Rabbit constantly outfoxed crafty Brer Fox— but this time it looks like it’s the hungry fox who has the upper hand. But never fear, quick-thinking Brer Rabbit will have the last laugh. First brought to life through Disney animation, these fanciful folklore critters have been immortalized in the classic Disney Theme Park attraction Splash Mountain. These fun-filled sculptures are plussed with a bronze fork and pewter neck on Brer Fox and a pewter pole for Brer Rabbit.”

The set was sculpted by Rubén Procopio, and the suggested retail price is $225.00 for the set. The full Summer 2010 catalog can be viewed on the official Walt Disney Classics Collection web site. Thanks to Michael Damato for the news report!

Song of the South Among TIME’s Top 10 Controversial Cartoons

In light of the recent censorship of the controversial cartoon series South Park, Claire Suddath of TIME Magazine looks back at the top 10 cartoons that have “caused a ruckus”. Walt Disney’s Song of the South comes in at #4 (though the list can be re-ordered by readers.)

Suddath states, “…there’s no denying the fact that by today’s standards, the film is rather racist. Set in the post–Civil War South, the movie — in which a former slave named Uncle Remus regales children with amusing stories — depicts an offensively “idyllic” master-slave relationship, as the NAACP once described it. Adam Clayton Powell Jr. considered the feature’s depictions of happy slaves an “insult to American minorities.” Disney has declined to release the film on video in the U.S., fearing an outcry over the crude stereotypes.”

Here is the list (in order): South Park and Muhammad, The Censored Eleven, The Simpsons and Brazil, Song of the SouthThe BoondocksFamily Guy and Sarah Palin, Pokémon Panic, AladdinSouth Park and Scientology, and the character Speedy Gonzales. It’s interesting to note that out of the ten, Song of the South is the only one to contain live action sequences (considered by many to be the most controversial aspect of the film). Also, only Song of the South and Aladdin (both by Disney) are full-length movies — the rest are TV episodes or short subject cartoons. And thirdly, it is one of only two entries from the 1940’s. So, have cartoons gotten more offensive, or are we just more sensitive? Both? Food for thought. The full article can be read here.

Song of the South has made some other “top” lists in the past as well, including Movies.com’s “The 25 Most Controversial Movies of All Time” (2007), and MSNBC’s “10 Least Politically Correct Movies Ever” (2006). Personally, the list I’d really like to see this movie on is Library of Congress’ National Film Registry. So if you haven’t already, please vote for Song of the South to be added to the 2010 National Film Registry!

One more list… Amazon.com’s “Top 100 All-Time Sign-Ups.” Which movie is still #1? Yep, you guessed it.

Disney CEO Calls Movie “Antiquated” and “Fairly Offensive”

Carol Koster of DisneyEcho.com has informed me that at this year’s Disney Shareholder Meeting in San Antonio, TX, the question was again posed to Disney CEO Robert Iger if Song of the South would finally be released on DVD.

Reporter Paul Bond of HollywoodReporter.com put it this way: “Calling the movie ‘antiquated’ and ‘fairly offensive,’ Iger said there are no plans for releasing ‘Song of the South’ on DVD.

“‘Thank you for not disappointing me,’ Iger said Wednesday after an attendee of the meeting in San Antonio asked about the 1946 film. It has become something of a tradition that someone will ask about ‘Song of the South’ at a Disney shareholders meeting, though Iger’s negative response this year seemed more firm than in the past.”

Koster also posted that Iger’s response seemed more pre-rehearsed than ever: “Mr. Iger thinks, and now in 2010 in his tone of voice is entrenched with the belief, that parts of the movie can be construed as offensive, and for that reason he will not authorize its release on home video in the US.”

While I’ve said it before, it’s worth saying again: for every year Disney doesn’t release this film, they lose more money to the bootleggers who are selling copies of this movie on the Internet. Please see my FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) on how we can make sure Disney knows we want this movie released.

Read the full news articles at:
DisneyEcho.com
HollywoodReporter.com

Thanks to Carol Koster and Joey Sartin for the news reports and sources.

Roy Disney Passes Away at Age 79

Today marks a very sad day: Roy E. Disney, nephew of Walt Disney, passed away at the age of 79 after fighting a year-long battle with stomach cancer.

Roy made headlines in 2003 when he and Stanley Gold stepped down from Disney’s board of directors and launched SaveDisney.com. SaveDisney.com was a wonderful web site filled with many well written articles, including several on Song of the South. Through his efforts and the voices of many unhappy shareholders, CEO Michael Eisner was effectively ousted in 2005. Roy later returned to Disney as “Director Emeritus”.

Some long-time readers may also remember my February 14, 2004 article in which Roy Disney expressed to me his support for the release of Song of the South. “Song of the South … happens to be one of my favorite of the old Disney films…. [Releasing] it would be one of my first acts if I were to come back to the company!” Sadly, he never got to see this come to fruition. Roy, you will be greatly missed by all.

Song of the South’s 63rd Anniversary

On this day 63 years ago, Song of the South made its worldwide debut at the Fox Theater in Atlanta, Georgia. Take a step back in time and look at the photos from the premier. Or, check out the 1946 Campaign page, which shows various memorabilia from the 1946 release. Also, be sure to check out the audio archives where you can hear some of the 1946 radio transcriptions, including James Baskett, Bobby Driscoll, Luana Patten, and Walt Disney himself with songs performed by Johnny Mercer.

I wish I could say that Disney will be releasing this movie soon, but there has been no news on that front. So if you haven’t already, please be sure to sign the petition and let your family & friends know about our efforts to get Disney to release this movie once and for all. Thanks!

Cartoon Brew Article: Who’s Afraid of Song of the South?

Jerry over at Cartoon Brew has asked the question, “Who’s afraid of Song of the South?” (That’s what we’d like to know too!) While at Comic Con, he picked up Issue 16 of Hogan’s Alley, which contains a 19-page article on Song of the South. In the article, the author Korkis “documents the complete story of the project, from pre-production to latter day reissues – with all the controversy inbetween”. According to Jerry, this is a must-read. I just ordered my copy as I write this, and I’m looking forward to reading it!

The Cartoon Brew article also shows some rare Ub Iwerks notes and production boards from Song of the South, from the collection of Mike Van Eaton. These are definitely worth viewing. Special thanks to Merlin Jones for the news report!

The full Cartoon Brew article can be read here:
http://www.cartoonbrew.com/disney/whos-afraid-of-song-of-the-south.html

To subscribe to Hogan’s Alley or order a copy of Issue 16, visit:
http://cagle.msnbc.com/hogan/subscribe.asp

Wikipedia Rumor: “Diamond Edition” Song of the South DVD

First, let me say that Wikipedia is by no means a reliable source for Song of the South rumors. The very nature of Wikipedia is that it can easily be revised by pretty much anyone. This leads to a lot of unfounded speculation, which amounts to no more than defacement in my opinion. However, in the interest of Song of the South rumors, I will post this. But, depending on how frequently Wikipedia rumors keep cropping up, I may become more selective as to which ones I report on, or I may stop posting on them altogether.

On May 9th, the following information was added to the Disney Special Editions page of Wikipedia by someone at the IP address 189.82.131.134:

Title Discs UK Release Date US Release Date Notes
Song of the South: 60th Anniversary Edition 2 May 2010 February 9, 2010 DVD and Blu-ray Disc – First release on DVD and Blu-ray Disc

There’s just one problem with this: Song of the South’s 60th anniversary was in 2006. This blatantly errant entry was removed two days later, on May 11th, by IP address 76.186.137.190.

Then, on May 23rd, the same IP (76.186.137.190) added Song of the South back on the list:

Title Discs UK Release Date US Release Date Notes
Song of the South: Diamond Edition 2 March 2012 March 13, 2012 Platinum Edition (US) (DVD/Blu-ray Disc) First Digital Release

Notice how the release date is now 2 years further away, but now is supposedly part of Disney’s new “Diamond Edition” series. This addition was removedonly 12 hours later by IP address 189.82.136.79.

So there you have it… basically what amounts to a cyber “tug of war” for Song of the South. One thing’s for certain: it hasn’t been released yet, and until it does Disney will just continue to lose money to the bootleggers out there.